Toxic Masculinity Is Not a Malfunction. It Is How Patriarchy Enforces Itself.
What if toxic masculinity is not a corruption of masculinity, but the predictable outcome of how it has been constructed? In this episode, Chisom Udeze examines the origins of the term and challenges its ability to explain systemic patterns of violence against women. Drawing on global data on gender-based violence, femicide, and sexual assault prosecutions, she asks whether calling masculinity toxic allows us to treat structural harm as an individual failure rather than confront the systems that produce it.
With Chisom Udeze
Listen On
Show Notes
Toxic masculinity was coined by a men’s movement that wanted to protect an authentic masculinity from blame, and the word still treats violence as the corruption of something good rather than the output of something built. Chisom tests that assumption against the record: 840 million women who have experienced partner or sexual violence in their lifetime, according to the World Health Organization, at rates that vary by region but sit at zero nowhere; 137 women and girls killed by a partner or family member every day in 2024, 60 percent of all female homicide victims against 11 percent of male victims; and, in England and Wales, a charge in only 2.6 percent of recorded rape offences. Chisom notes what the argument does not claim, that every act is a conscious decision, and about what it does explain, is the rate. The word toxic lets you look away from a design and call it an accident. This episode asks you to start seeing it as it is.
--
A note on two figures in this episode. The description of the home as the most dangerous place for a woman, follows the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, whose own 2018 study used that framing. The data behind it measures who kills women, partners and family members, rather than where the killing happens, and the most recent UN Women and UNODC report notes that data on location remains limited. The argument stands on the relationship figures: in 2024, 60 percent of women and girls killed worldwide were killed by a partner or family member, against 11 percent of male homicide victims. Second, the 49.1 percent conviction rate for England and Wales covers all prosecutions the Crown Prosecution Service completed between July and September 2024, most of which ended in a guilty plea, not only cases that went to trial. The estimate of roughly one conviction for every seventy or eighty reported rapes combines figures from different periods, and should be read as an illustration of scale rather than a precise measure.